Pairwise Preference Method

A Pairwise Preference Method is a preference elicitation method that collects binary comparisons between paired alternatives to establish relative quality rankings through direct comparison.

• AKA: Pairwise Preference Judgment, Binary Preference Comparison, Head-to-Head Judgment Method, Pairwise Choice Method, A/B Preference Test.
• Context:
  • It can typically present Two Alternatives for simultaneous comparison.
  • It can typically reduce Cognitive Load compared to absolute rating.
  • It can often aggregate into Global Rankings via preference models.
  • It can often exhibit Position Bias favoring first-presented options.
  • It can support Bradley-Terry Model fitting for ability estimation.
  • It can enable Transitivity Analysis of preference consistency.
  • It can facilitate Tie Detection when alternatives are equivalent.
  • It can integrate with Active Learning for efficient sampling.
  • It can range from being a Forced-Choice Pairwise Method to being a Tie-Allowed Pairwise Method, depending on its response options.
  • It can range from being a Blind Pairwise Method to being an Informed Pairwise Method, depending on its source visibility.
  • It can range from being a Single-Aspect Pairwise Method to being a Multi-Aspect Pairwise Method, depending on its evaluation dimensions.
  • It can range from being an Expert Pairwise Method to being a Crowd Pairwise Method, depending on its annotator type.
  • ...
• Examples:
  • NLG Pairwise Preference Methods, such as:
    • Translation Pairwise Preference Method for MT system comparison.
    • Summary Pairwise Preference Method for summarization quality.
    • Response Pairwise Preference Method for chatbot evaluation.
  • Platform-Based Preference Methods, such as:
    • Chatbot Arena Preference Method for LLM comparison.
    • SummEval Pairwise Method for benchmark evaluation.
  • Criterion-Specific Preference Methods, such as:
    • Fluency Pairwise Method for language quality.
    • Helpfulness Pairwise Method for utility assessment.
  • ...
• Counter-Examples:
  • Pointwise Rating Method, which evaluates single items independently.
  • Listwise Ranking Method, which orders multiple items simultaneously.
  • Absolute Scoring Method, which assigns numerical values directly.
• See: Preference Elicitation Method, Bradley-Terry Model, Thurstone Preference Model, Pairwise Comparison Method, Human Evaluation Method, Ranking Aggregation Algorithm, Position Bias, Tie Handling Method, Preference Learning.

---